My continuing blog posts about the Governments Digital Britain will continue up to the point that the final document is completed by Lord Carter. Probably go on beyond that – but some news and initiatives trickling out last night – really got my back up (as some of you would have seen!) and its here that futurists and strategic thinkers that look beyond the here and now and delve further into the future into a landscape that is very different to the one that we see today – so the indication that the Government will set up a “rights agency” for the web really started to make my blood boil. Not really with the fact that here is another Government set on regulating the web – but actually not getting the point of it at all and why file sharing will continue way beyond the pathetic laws that they are planning.

Firstly – here is a snippet from the Guardian that alerted me to the plans from Lord Carter to create a “digital rights agency” and how does he plan to actually police this? We have seen regimes and countries try to clamp down on access and limit the amount of data that their citizens can see / read / watch / access… – but these are Communist states that want to control the flow of information that their Citizens consume. Now last time I checked we were a democracy (in the loosest form of the word these days)

Quick background check…. So in essence there is still a need to go all out to prevent the Music industry in particular, from being crushed by the powers of the illegal file sharers? However in this current climate – apart from Pinnacle – how are the other music labels holding up at the moment? Are they asking for huge hand outs from the Government for aid before their business goes to the toilet? Nope! Why – because they are making a huge amount of money from their digital sales – which are increasing by around 25% YoY – not making up the shortfall in CD sales I grant you – but again – this is now 2009 – times have moved on and consumers have moved with the times. So gone are the heady days of the 70s, 80s &90s where multi-million album sales and single sales are the norm. It just doesn't work that way anymore. This has to be the first lesson for them – just as the banks are being reigned in again – the music industry needs a slap in the face that wakes them up to the reality.

Next slap in the face must go to the artists that seem to be demanding bigger royalty payment based on their “stature”, “success” or catalogue! Again the times have changed – the next breed of consumers Gen Y & Gen Z are very different animals and see and perceive music and its consumption in a very different way – and I keep sounding like a broken record here – but these are the fundamentals that need to be addressed and understood before we can actually move forward. Look at the sheer greed of some artists thinking that they should be paid more on You Tube – even though this is now a way that users discover music and artists – just as radio used to in the past – but this time the attention / consumption is very different (as well as the quality) Billy Bragg, Robbie Williams, Blur all meet today at their FAC (Featured Artist Coalition – or Fading Artists Cry) Summit where Blur’s Dave Rowntree said "YouTube's row with the PRS is the most recent example of just how fast the music industry is changing." – What you’ve only just realised that!! Now that may sound harsh – but the You Tube example and what Billy Brag said about the whole You Tube affair with talk of Artists Unions etc..  I think that artists need to look at themselves and importantly their labels – that own their copyright and publishing rights. If you have signed your life away to your ecord company for a fast buck in your early careers – and now see your video on You Tube and get a few pence for it – then ask yourself what is my record label getting from that – and actually what is my video on You Tube really worth in todays market? What is Artists Market Value in the social media world of 2009. Perhaps answer those questions first internally before shooting Google down! Hope that is on the agenda today!

So how does this tie into what the Government regulation and rules? Well with the announcement of the digital rights agency (proposed) what value will they bring and is this just about music or other formats and types going to be covered by this agency. ISPs will monitor the flow of P2P traffic and under legislation decide to target, trace and monitor torrents that are delivering illegal content! That all sounds great – now we know that ISPs can (and should have been) following the P2P traffic for a long time – what is contained within them is another matter! I guess if your Torrent is tagged or labelled as “Beatles_White_Album” then yes I would say that this is an album containing the Beatles tracks – you could go further if the torrent contains 30tracks and is around 210mb – then yes you are going to track that one down… well done {claps hands} What if the entire Beatles catalogue was on a Torrent labelled as “CM3u0yKuF” zipped up into chunks – Secure Zips are tagged as HolidayFiles_France_88: is there smart technology that knows how to get around that?? If there is then – fantastic  - but then if we have level of penetration detection on networks then is it not more appropriate to after that technology to go after the trap doors and hidden doors into the seedy underground world of child pornography – where although not costing an industry any financial hardship – its something more important – children's lives! I’ve talked about this before – where its always a subject that is hard for people to talk about openly but none the less there should be a task force beyond what we have to ensure that if we are going to monitor internet usage then – surely this should be one of the first port of calls?

So in final ranting fashion what are we saying – P2P is in fact a dying breed and the shares already know this – what you find is that the ones that are left and being charged are not the hardcore that need to be brought to task here – and by that I don't mean some lengthy prison sentence. The technology has moved so far away that I have seen and tried out the new breed of illegal file share sites – as they finish the UI and monetisation (these guys that set up Pirate Bay & KaZaA etc know what they are doing) and you know what in a seamless silent world there is over 5Tb of media on there just now in some of these sites – with the latest Hollywood blockbusters (US cinema releases such as Watchmen..) that come over the wire under the noses of the ISPs with no detection – because they have moved away from Torrents and into a whole new venture. I’m not going to name any names or anything like that – also doesn't really work like that anymore is all I’m saying.

So once the Government, UK Music, Lord Carter and ISPs finally agree to take action – it will be a barren wasteland of dead empty torrents and a few people who stumbled across it while trying to find a music video that used to be on You Tube until the greedy artists decided they wanted more $ from Google (because they can afford it?? argument from artists!)

Big Brother will be watching – but what exactly will it be watching….?